What is zero-based budgeting and is it right for you?
Create a budget where “spending” every dollar is good.
Contributing Writer at Tally
April 18, 2020
Budgeting can be one of the more challenging parts of adult life. Fortunately, there are many budgeting methods that make the process easier. Zero-based budgeting, often shortened to ZBB, is one such method that uses specific financial goals as its driver.
Below, we’ll explore ZBB and how it differs from traditional budgeting. We’ll also review its benefits and drawbacks, so you can decide if it’s the right technique for you.
What is zero-based budgeting?
Zero-based budgeting is a process that ensures you "spend" every dollar you earn and not a penny more.
Spending every dollar doesn't mean blowing it on whatever you like. It means ensuring every dollar you earn goes toward a line item on your budget. This way, when you finish creating your budget, your expenses are equal to your income, hence the zero-base term.
For example, if your monthly take-home income is $3,000, you want to adjust your budget so your expenses also equal $3,000. If your zero-based budgeting is off in either the expense or income column, you can make adjustments each month to zero it out.
In zero-based budgeting, you may carry over some recurring expenses from month to month. However, you still create a new budget each month that accounts for extra income and unexpected or variable costs.
How does zero-based budgeting differ from traditional budgeting?
While a zero-based budget looks forward at expenses and income, traditional budgeting looks backward. Instead of adjusting your budget to reach $0 remaining each month, traditional budgeting uses historical income and expenses.
Traditional budgeting allows very little flexibility but is less time consuming than zero-based budgeting because you set it up at the beginning of the year. Also, traditional budgeting only requires adjustments when there are significant changes to your income or expenses.
For example, if you spent an average of $100 per month on electricity last year, you would base your current budget on that number, plus any anticipated rate increases. This number would remain the same for the entire year, barring any changes, like a switch to solar panels or moving into a larger home that consumes more electricity.
With ZBB, you would use your actual electric bill to calculate the monthly expense.
How do you start zero-based budgeting?
The thought of making a new budget each month and tracking it may seem intimidating. However, in reality, portions of your budget may remain the same each month. The most common changes will be variable expenses like water, electricity and fuel. Once you get started creating your zero-based budget, you'll find it all makes sense. Here's how to get started.
1. Add up all your monthly take-home income
Kick off your zero-based budgeting by first looking at your monthly take-home income. Don't calculate this using your pretax income, as you'll come up short every month.
If you just started a new job and haven't received your first paycheck yet, you can estimate your take-home pay through various paycheck calculating websites.
If you have irregular income — for example, working on commission or as a contractor — ZBB shines as a budgeting method because you start fresh each month and can adjust your income to match what you made the previous month. So, if your sales were a little light this month, you can change next month's budget to compensate for that.
2. Add up your regular monthly expenses
Expenses can get tricky, as you have two types of bills to track: regular and irregular.
Cell phone bill
Car payment and fuel
There’s no doubt you'll run into months where surprise expenses fall into your lap, but we’ll cover that in a bit.
3. Add up your irregular expenses
Irregular expenses are often forgotten until they're due. Fortunately, the zero-based budgeting method puts them front and center along with the rest of your bills. These expenses include longer-term items like:
Car insurance payments (quarterly)
Property taxes (yearly)
When looking at irregular expenses, calculate their overall yearly cost, then spread that out over 12 months. For example, if your quarterly car insurance is $250, that would equal $1,000 per year, which would break down to $83.33 per month in your zero-based budget. If you have an irregular bill that fluctuates, use the previous year's budget to estimate the yearly cost.
Other irregular expenses to consider are holidays, birthdays, anniversaries and other times where you plan to spend extra money. If you plan to spend $300 on birthday gifts during the year, break down the amount ($300) by month and put that amount ($25) into your zero-based budget each month.
You can account for those surprise expenses that seem to pop up at the worst times with a monthly "miscellaneous" budget. To ease the calculation, you can base this amount on past unexpected expenses.
If you didn't track these surprise expenses in previous years, it's OK to estimate. This amount will likely be small relative to your other costs.
When dealing with irregular expenses, set this cash aside for when the expense is due. If you want to take it a step further, create a separate bank account where you can stash this money.
Putting this cash for your irregular expenses in a savings account not only helps keep you from mistakenly spending it, but it can also earn interest as you await the bill's due date.
4. Subtract your expenses from your income
Now for the main event. Subtract your total monthly expenses from your monthly take-home income. If your expenses equal your income, you already have a zero-based budget.
In most cases, you will either end up with an income shortage or surplus.
What if I have an income shortage?
If you have a negative number after subtracting your expenses from your income, you have an income shortage. You can manage this by increasing your income, cutting costs or both.
If you’re looking to boost your income, start by asking for a raise or trying to work more hours. These options aren’t always available, but they allow you to stay within your current job. If you’re looking outside your current job, you might also consider:
Drive-for-hire (people or deliveries)
Sell crafts or other items
If you’re looking to cut your costs, determine what services you can live without. Start with those you rarely use and continue from there. Even if it's a $1-per-month charge, cutting that expense can make a difference. Look at expenses like streaming services, mail-order video or game rentals, unused software subscriptions, and more.
You can also call your credit card companies to negotiate your interest rates and lower your monthly minimum payments.
If you have a profound shortage, you may have to make more dramatic changes, such as selling the car you're making payments on and buying a less expensive vehicle with cash or taking public transit.
Continue your cost-cutting until you at least hit the zero-base budget you seek. If you can create an income surplus in the process, that's just the cherry on top.
What if you have an income surplus?
If you have an income surplus, you're in good shape. But there's still work to do. The goal of zero-based budgeting is to have $0 left in your budget when you're done, so figure out where that extra money in your budget will go.
In a zero-based budget, this extra cash should first go toward debt or savings. If you haven't created an emergency fund yet, you’ll want your income surplus to go toward this first.
Most experts recommend having 3-6 months of expenses in savings to cover emergencies like job loss or illness. However, if you have credit card debt, you can use the surplus income to build an initial $1,000 emergency fund, then prioritize lowering your debt.
Once you pay off your credit cards and manage any other high-interest debt, you can shift back toward building an emergency fund to cover the recommended 3-6 months of expenses.
With the completed emergency fund, you can earmark any surplus income toward retirement savings, savings for a house or car, or any other financial goals you have.
5. Track your expenses and reset
With your budget firmly set, it's time to track your spending. Categorize and notate every dollar you spend. For example, if you go to the movies and spend $50, deduct that $50 from the "fun money" line item in your budget.
You can track your expenses in many ways. Some people prefer a simple notebook and pencil. Others may create a spreadsheet or use online budgeting software.
At the end of the month, review your budget to see where you exceeded or came in under budget. Make any necessary adjustments to your budget the following month.
You will likely make a lot of changes early on. As time passes, you’ll improve your budgeting and financial foresight, reducing the amount of updating you must do each month. Eventually, you may be able to create a monthly budget template that only requires mild tweaks to your income and variable expenses, saving you lots of time.
Is zero-based budgeting right for you?
Zero-based budgeting isn't for everyone, but it’s a great fit for some folks.
If you’re goal-oriented and struggle with traditional budgeting because it lacks the clear end benefit, the ZBB model is perfect. It funnels your money into two primary financial goals to keep you motivated: saving and paying off debt.
If your income fluctuates because you're on commission or are a contractor, the zero-based method of budgeting will suit you because it can vary each month. The same goes if you have a lot of variable expenses, like medical bills or home repairs.
Tracking all of your expenses requires keeping your receipts in order, which can be time-consuming. As such, ZBB is ideal for someone who's organized and enjoys spending time handling their finances.
Pros of zero-based budgeting
Adjusts for monthly fluctuations in income and expenses
Every dollar has a job to do
Puts a lot of focus on key financial goals
More precise than traditional budgeting
Cons of zero-based budgeting
Can become time-consuming
No set-it-and-forget-it mode
The uneasy feeling of "spending" every dollar
Get your budget started
With a firm understanding of what a zero-based budget is, how it works, and its pros and cons, you can determine whether it'll fit your lifestyle. Even if it’s not the right approach for you, there's no time like the present to get your budget together. Creating your budget now will help you get your financial life in order so you can reach your financial goals sooner than later.